Through out the hype period before it’s actual launch, the images of the Pre concerned me a bit. With all the curves, I thought it would be a bit too femalish for me, but when you actually get to play with the device, it has this cool alienish futuristic look to it. Touchstone also adds to this coolness.
Keyboard
The keyboard is fine if you are coming from older devices like the Treo but am not sure if you are coming from the newer BlackBerrys. That might take more time getting used to. I have been using the iPhone over the past year and since the Pre is also a touch screen, one tends to start out using it like the iPhone. However, with the full qwerty keyboard, you can get around much quicker and get things done faster.
Set Up
Setting things up is really sweet and fast. Since this is essentially a cloud phone, you just enter you email info, im info etc and you are good to go. I was even pleasantly surprised being able to set up the my Gx5 email without having to sync with my Desktop. I think this may have to do with some of the magic they got from the Chattermail acquisition.
Multitasking
Palm’s implementation of multitasking is just absolutely wonderful. The card paradigm is the sweetness thing I have ever seen on a Smartphone.
Fatter is better
The Pre feels better in your hand than the iPhone. For once, thin is not better.
Third Party Apps
Even though the App catalog has a limited no. of apps, using these apps validate WebOS as a platform to create powerful and useful apps. Even more exciting is what is going on in the hacking/jailbreak scene, where like the iPhone, you will soon see some mind blowing apps.
Societal Factor
Unlike previous awesome Palm devices that know one in mainstream knew about, the Palm Pre is an attention getter. I have been stopped quite a few times by curious folks wanting to know more about the Pre. Also, Palm's markting has been great.
Seeing ads like this makes you feel good owning one.
Gripes
Would prefer they kept the menu/option button next to the sym key like we had on older Treos.
While people will love the interface, I have some issues with the design of some of the U.I. elements. To a layman they all look good, but to a top notch graphic artist, some of these U.I. elements look cheesy.
I think the top status bar/bottom alert area concept is great but the implementation is a bit flawed. I don’t see why they can’t be combined into one and placed permanently in the bottom. It saves real estate and makes things easier to touch.
The downside of this captive screen is that you can’t use your nails and that makes it a bit harder to put the cursor between words. That may sound crazy to you, but this is what us Treonauts have been used to.
Palm should stop being iPhonish in certain areas. For example, why go away from the sensible alphabetical listing of apps for the absolutely stupid iPhone way of laying out apps in just random silliness. By week 2, you don’t even know where your apps are any more.
The maps app needs a lot of work!
The slide out keyboard is cool, but it really slows things down. I like to get things done as fast as possible so having to always slide out wastes time. This is not a play phone like the iPhone where I need a wide screen to watch videos. This is a work phone. I need to get stuff done asap. So I will really be looking forward to the Eos with it’s always available keyboard.
So which one: iPhone or Palm Pre?
For me, both. Palm Pre is great for working and getting things done. I won’t recommend it as a multimedia device anytime soon. On the other hand, the iPhone is great for multimedia and if you jailbreak it you can do
some amazingly cool stuff.
Right now, WebOS will be my work device, while the iPhone will be more of my multimedia device. If you are coming from a Treo, WebOS is absolutely awesome, but I would wait till
Eos is released as it will be an easier transition because WebOS would have been more matured and have more apps. If you are using a dumb phone then stop being dumb and go get the Pre now.
Recent Comments